Trumpeter in May

For the May meeting, I decided to get involved with some micro micro armour. 3mm to be precise and they are very good Oddzial Osmy (Picoarmour) models in that I can figure out what type a tank each one is supposed to represent.

I played the German commander of a Kampfgruppe composed of teachers and students from a tank training school pitted against a brigade of British tanks. Basically, it was their 45 tanks vs my 13. On the positive side, 4 of mine were Tiger 1s and 2s along with 5 Panthers. However, half the British tanks were Fireflies with those nasty 17lbers.

I decided on a defense on depth with the Panthers blocking the left, which represented the most covered approach. I put my junkiest units up front on the right, and the heavy hitting Tigers at the back to keep the range as long as I could for as long as I could. I put one minefield on the extreme left to prevent slipping around the back of the Panthers while the other minefield would prevent the British from setting up a good fire line on some key hills.

Things started out moderately well with the Panthers taking out some Shermans way out on the far right making up for the blindness of the student tank hunters on the right. That caused the one company to fall back.

As a knock-on effect, the Sherman company on my left thought better of going up the centre out in the open and went around the hill to my far left. While they were doing that, my Panthers, Tigers, and others proceeded to pound the centre Sherman company.

However, it was not entirely one-sided. As I was reducing the centre and right Shermans, they did manage to wipe out my two units of tank hunters, which left me with nothing on the right. But while the remnants of the centre and right companies worked their way down the right (joined by the 4th company, which was created from earlier casualties), I turned my attention back to the leftmost Sherman company. A quick duel turned into a rout at the cost of a single Panther and the Sherman company retreated back around the hill, only to eventually reappear in the center after a couple of turns.

Eventually the weight of numbers began to tell as the Tigers brewed up under the attention of the Sherman companies on the right. Then the Panthers began to die until the German side had only one Tiger 2 and one Panther facing more than a dozen Shermans, at which we called the game. The Germans had killed more than 2 Shermans for each of their own casualties but it just wasn't enough against all of those Fireflies.

Chris has written a pretty interesting set of rules that have a lot of potential. They flow well and are pretty simple. I think the one refinement that needs to happen is to ditch the precision of the gun penetrations and adopt the simpler system he has for the armour.

Trumpeter Salute 2019

 (Apologies for the bad photos but the lens on my phone is badly scratched and smudged)

On April 13th, I went to Trumpeter Salute 2019, which is the biggest miniature war gaming convention in the Vancouver area. They had a good selection of games last year so I was really looking forward to this year's event.

A new feature they had this year was an online game registration where you could pre-register for one game. Very good idea and I hope they continue it next year.

Game 1

This was my pre-registration game. The rules were General D'Armee and the battle was Maxheim, which featured the French battling a combined Prussian-Russian force. One of the quirks of the allied side was that the Prussians had brigades on both flanks with the Russians in the centre.

In an omen on how things were to go, the French won the initiative and immediately occupied the village to my front. I decided I was not going to assault the village and instead opted for a delaying action, especially as we needed command dice to re-position a Prussian cavalry brigade to counter a French cavalry brigade. 

Being on the left flank, I'm a little fuzzy on the details on what happened on the right, but a disaster happened early over on the right where the Prussian cavalry and infantry routed. My contribution was to roll 0 aide d'camps out of 6 dice to try and rescue them. I think the Umpire just moved them back to the edge of the board rather than off. 

Meanwhile, on my side, I had lured the French beyond the garrison range and got ready to counterattack. First attempt met with a 12 rolled for casualties and my charge pretty much stopped before it could begin. Second attempt actually led to us rolling for the charge effect, but me rolling a 2 compared to a 10 or something saw another fail. 

I love the rules but this was a brutal game to play. All of the key die rolls by the Prussians and Russians were miserable failures.

Game 2

Mongolmania pitted Mongols against Rus in an all cavalry battle using Lion Rampant rules.  The Mongols started as a massive horde at one end of the table with three different groups of Rus trying to prevent them from exiting off the other side. Colin modified the rules slightly so that a failure to activate a unit didn't end your turn. Also, he had some special effects for rolling a 2 or a 12 when activating a unit.

I took a group of Rus. There wasn't much strategy in this and it was close. The turning point came quite late in the game. I had a unit of light horse that got the benefit of +1 to hit with archery and +1 to bravery because of a couple of 12s I had rolled. This unit was like a tactical nuke in that it took out 5 Mongolian units and it was untouched, while most of the remaining Mongolian units were pretty worn down (as were the Rus as well). However, a Mongolian player rolled a 12 and got a free shot on my super unit. Worse, he rolled really well and took out 3 figures. I then rolled a 2 for morale and that was it.

With not much Rus left, Colin declared the Mongols the victor in a close and bloody fight. Good fun!

Game 3

 In this game, the French were out to burn down a British fort using the Musket and Tomahawk rules. I was commanding the British provincial regulars in the fort and the provincial militia and Indians in the woods. Marching to my relief were two units of Scots regulars and two units of rangers. The French surprised me a bit by starting out on the far right instead of closer.

I decided to get aggressive with my Indians and advanced them into the woods that I expected the French to have been in. After a little hesitation, I advanced my militia down the centre. This turned out to be a minor mistake that lead to bad consequences. Meanwhile, the French slowly moved on the far right, staying largely out of sight in the woods.

My Indians reached the far edge of the woods and got into a musketry duel with 3 units of French irregulars. Despite being outnumbered, over the rest of the game, the British Indians decimated the French irregulars with remarkably accurate musketry. The British Indians suffered 2 total casualties while the French lost 30 of 36. However, the French did achieve their objective of keeping the British Indians away from the rest of the French forces (and even distracted British militia a bit).

Meanwhile, back at the fort, my regulars saw little until the French Indians and more irregulars arrived within 6" of the fort. (Seriously, who the heck builds a fort that close to dense woods?)

A remarkably poor morale roll saw my regular retreat from the walls early in the turn. That really was the game because the French Indians used remarkably effective flaming arrows to set the walls alight and also ran up to the wall and use torches.

Even getting a unit of regulars into the fort had little effect. The fire arrows were too effective and there were too many Indians and the fort started to burn.

Credit to the French for coming up with a good plan and being persistent in executing it, even if they left the French irregulars to get massacred by the British Indians.

(Photos to come)

What If: Japan vs Russia naval battle

This Friday, it was naval gaming at Craig's. The scenario was a 1914 encounter with the Russian navy protecting a convoy of troop carriers that were set to invade Korea.

The Russian navy had 4 modern ships and 4 pre-dreadnoughts facing off against a Japanese fleet with 2 semi-modern ships (or maybe they were also pre-dreadnoughts), 2 ultramodern Kongo class battlecruisers, and 6 pre-dreadnoughts. As I arrived just as things were getting started, I got 2 of the Japanese pre-dreadnoughts and I really didn't get a chance to see what the other ships were.

So the Japanese sort-of plan was to sail the pre-dreadnoughts straight at the heart of the Russian fleet to try to burst through and get at the convoy. The ships on the left were to swing over to the right and combine with the BCs to push that flank. The Russian plan was to delay the convoy for a couple of turns, combine all of their modern ships over the right as well (setting up for an epic clash), and swing their pre-dreadnoughts over to the left to protect that area and stay out of trouble.

The battle plans went awry right away. The Russian ships on the far right immediately ran into trouble with some lucky hits devastating them early. They remained floating for a number of turns but they were gone in turn 4 and turn 6 (I think). The other Russian modern ships attracted a lot of attention and suffered some loss in firepower and speed but were still in pretty good shape. The Japanese charge of the pre-dreadnoughts did have the benefit of attracting fire from these ships instead of at the heavier hitting Japanese modern fleet. It cost the Japanese a couple of pre-dreadnoughts by the end of the game.


Meanwhile, on the Japanese left, the plan to sail to the right was abandoned and they kept up a heavy fire the modern Russian ships now in the centre. As the Russian pre-dreadnoughts swung around in front of them, they began fire on them as well.

By the end of the game, the Russian fleet was in serious trouble. The modern elements of the Japanese navy were untouched and beginning to pound on the Russian modern ships. The Japanese pre-dreadnoughts in the centre were beginning to break through but were a bit worse for wear.



The battle really turned on the Japanese getting really good and lucky hits on the right and the charge of the pre-dreadnoughts attracting the Russian attention away from the modern ships in the Japanese fleet.

General D'Armee at Trumpeter

So for the February edition of Trumpeter, I played in a game of General D'Armee. It was a refight of Quatre Bras with an Anglo-Dutch force trying to prevent the French from capturing the crossroads.

I took the Dutch brigade on the right consisting of 2 regular battalions, 2 green battalions, a battery, and 3 stands of skirmishers. My right was anchored on woods and to my left was a British brigade. Facing me was a brigade with another one pointed at the junction between me and the British brigade.

We got the initiative and immediately I sacrificed one of the green battalions to reinforce the skirmish screen. If I hadn't, I think I would have been overwhelmed quickly. The opening cannonades played havoc with the packed French deployment (lots of high die rolls) and the skirmishers also did quite well.

As the game progressed I gave ground slowly and the French artillery began to take its toll on my line troops. Additionally, my artillery eventually succumbed to skirmisher fire. Fortunately, they had taken quite a toll on the French before they quit the field.

(I had a picture to insert here but it has disappeared. I may have accidentally deleted it)

Meanwhile, on my left, the British brigade had been doing reasonably well holding up the French but they were being threatened by a small cavalry brigade to their left rear. At this point, our reserve brigade made a timely arrival after marching rapidly across from right to left. Using a forward tasking, they launched a long distance charge with the two attached cavalry regiments. We had a slight disadvantage going in but rolled sufficiently well to get into combat. At this point, the Dice Gods deserted us. Throwing 10D6 with a 4-6 meaning a hit, we could only cause two casualties. Coming back was 6D6 that caused 5 (I think). Our cavalry returned from whence it came.

Meanwhile, an elite British battalion charged a hesitant French column. The French player rolled a 12 and caused 3 casualties and morale test, which the British battalion promptly failed. At least both brigades passed their faltering check (as I did too when I lost my battery).

At this point, the game was called with a marginal French victory because they had the crossroads. A fair enough result because, short of a drastic change in luck, the French were grinding the Allies down anyway.

I really like these rules. They move deceptively quickly (in that while movement rates aren't that high, there's definitely the ability to close rapidly and get stuck in), there's a lot of command choice, and losing even a single unit can really hurt. I have the similar Pickett's Charge but I haven't fully read them yet. I can't wait to try them out, once I have figures for them.

An apology and New Year's resolutions

I can't believe that it has been 18 months since my last post. It's for this long long pause in posting that I am apologizing for. I've been meaning to post for quite a while now but somehow I never got around to it. I'm sorry.

I guess I should explain some of the reasons for the absence. Shortly after my last post, I returned to Ontario to pack for our long journey to BC. We arrived and survived in a small 320 square foot apartment for the rest of 2016. Let me tell you that I am not cut our for tiny house living. It's also pretty devastating for my miniatures hobby because I had to leave them in storage.

We bought a house in Abbotsford and moved in over the month of December. My miniatures have a home in the nice finished basement and all my books that I kept are up on shelves where I can access them. However, it's an older home and we've ended up doing a lot of renovations. The renovations have chewed up quite a bit of time but they are coming to an end. I just have the stairwell left to patch and paint.

On to the resolutions; in 2019 I resolve to:

• Post at least once a month in this blog. I won't count this one for January though.
• Create terrain that I can use for my 2mm ACW figures. Maybe my next post could describe my plans for this.
• Write a set of rules for an age of sail game. I have been mulling a few ideas in my mind and I think it's time to put pen to paper, as it were.
• Paint more 6mm WW2 figures.

Trumpeter in June

Having done two back-to-back naval games, I thought it would be a good idea to switch things up a bit at the next Trumpeter meeting. That's how I ended up playing War of 1812.

We used a set rules called Land of the Free. Let me start out be saying that I'm not really a fan of what I've seen in these rules. Maybe we made some fundamental mistakes but it seems like units can do a lot of things in a turn, like shoot three times. Now I'll concede that I had really crappy die rolling (I think I only passed morale checks for the artillery all game) and that definitely played a role in how I view these rules. I do think a game should be able to compactly summarize itself into 2-4 quick reference pages. For some reason, these rules use 6 pages and there's no reason they shouldn't have been on 4.

Let me explain what happened prior to the picture. On the left, not much happened all game. I advanced three units to the fence and I was content to leave them there to protect my left and the guns. You are seeing it beginning to crumble because I could not make any morale rolls and my units had to retreat.

On my right, I sent an entire brigade of a large unit, a unit of skirmishers, a medium unit, and a small militia unit vs one large unit (plus one 1/2 unit that could fire out of the house). My skirmisher went first and had no effect but they were driven back. Next turn, I advanced my medium unit and my large unit. The British responded with delayed fire and naturally drove my medium unit back before I could fire myself (reasonable enough, I suppose). My large unit fired twice with little effect, mostly because of crappy die rolls. The British won the initiative and fired three times on my large unit. Each fire was 8 dice and hit on a 5-6. That's basically 2-3 hits per firing and every 4 hits drops the unit's morale by 1. Combine that firepower with my miserable die rolling for hits and morale and I didn't achieve anything. It wasn't until I managed to sneak a small unit of militia onto the road that I managed to get enough hits on the British unit to drop it a level of morale.

Shortly after this photo, my two American units routed leaving only the militia behind. It was at that point, we called the game.

To me, these rules seem too fiddly for playing a lot of units but they also seem to need a lot of units to smooth out the swings in luck. But I'd be willing to give them another go just to see if knowing how they work would improve how they play.

Gaming at Craig's

I had enjoyed playing in a naval game at the May Trumpeter. I was happy that they invited me to join them in their regular gaming every Friday. So off I went the following weekend to yet another naval game. This time, it was WW2 with a semi-home brew set of rules call (I believe) Steel Fleets.

Once again, I took the van but being a little smarter, I choose to try to keep the distance open a bit since we were outgunning our opponents. (Unfortunately, our second division seemed to have missed the briefing on when to turn.)

This shot was reasonably early in the game. Eventually, I was able to cross the T (although it's really not a huge advantage to do so in these rules). Some of our ships were pounded but opposing fleet got hammered.

These rules are interesting but the gunnery seems pretty fiddly and the torpedo rules especially so. If I were to compare them (and I haven't played that much naval gaming), I'd say that the rules strongly resemble Avalon Hill's Bismark, especially the special damage chart.

I enjoy them but I think there's an over-emphasis on the number of guns. I'm not so sure that a ship with 4x3 guns should be more than twice as effective than one with 3x2 and it is in these rules. The advantage really comes into play at the longer ranges where there's a reward for having hit your opponent in the previous turn. The 12 tubes have a much greater chance of picking up that advantage and that's why the number of tubes rules.